03 November 2023
14 min read
#Government, #Construction, Infrastructure & Projects
Published by:
Government principals and their contract management consultants must be extra diligent in assessing and responding to payment claims under the security of payment regime as a result of a recent case in New South Wales that will be equally applicable in Queensland.
In the case of Turnkey v Witron, the NSW Supreme Court held that the payment schedule was invalid under section 14 of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) (NSW Act). In relation to its relevance to Queensland, this provision is similar to section 69 of the Building Industry fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (QLD) (Qld Act), with the terminology of each set out below:
The case involved the principal (Witron) and the contractor (Turnkey) entering a contract for electrical installation works at a fixed price of $11.4 million. As a result of delays and an issue with the scope of works, the contractor sought to re-price the contract at $14,141,951.32.
After numerous email exchanges in April 2023, it appeared that both parties had agreed to the new contract price. On 1 May 2023, the contractor served the principal with a payment claim for $499,924.63 for the contract works and $304,230 for 10 identified variations. Two days after, the principal sent an email to the contractor, which they later claimed was the payment schedule. The email appeared to conflict with the emails in April regarding the acceptance of the revised contract price. The case then turned to whether the email constituted a valid payment schedule.
The case determined that a payment schedule must contain reasons that are “clear enough” to indicate why payment is being withheld. Whether a payment schedule is clear will be entirely dependent on the construction of the payment schedule, the words that are used and what can be inferred.
However, what is of particular interest is the Court’s response to the partial reasoning provided by the principal in response to the payment claim. In this case, it was established that the principal had provided reasons for withholding payment for 60 per cent of the items for which payment was withheld, but failed to give reasons for the remaining 40 per cent. Although there was adequate reasoning for most of the payment schedule, the failure to provide reasoning for the remaining portion resulted in the entirety of the payment schedule being invalid.
This outcome means that the party responding to a payment claim cannot ignore part of the claim for which money is being withheld and must address every aspect of the payment claim, providing clear reasons for withholding payment. However, whilst the reasons must be clear, the NSW Act does not require “that the reasons given be correct, justified or adequate.” The Qld Act also provides no basis under section 69(c) for a reason to be correct, it just must be stated within the payment schedule.
If Queensland courts take the same approach as done in NSW, it will have significant consequences for those issuing payment schedules (including government principals and their consultants) because, if a payment schedule does not adequately address every aspect of the payment claim, the party responding to the claim will be held liable to pay the full amount claimed despite providing reasons for withholding payment on most of the items for which payment was being withheld.
Arguably, a better interpretation of section 14 of the NSW Act would be that the requirement to provide reasons in the payment schedule be viewed as an opportunity to do so. This would ensure that any consequence would be the onus of the respondent rather than invalidating the entire payment schedule. Such a consequence would bring into effect section 20(2B) of the NSW Act, which is akin to section 82(4) of the Qld Act, effectively barring the respondent from raising reasons that had not been identified in the payment schedule.
If government principals on construction projects wish to avoid future disputes, the best approach is to ensure that every part of the payment claim is carefully assessed and that appropriate reasons be given for any withheld payments. This results in both parties having a much better understanding of each other’s position on payment.
If you have any questions about the legislation in Queensland or how to ensure that progress certificates and payment schedules are appropriately prepared, please get in touch with a member of our team below.
Authors: Kirsty Smith & Laura Guise
Once-in-a-generation rewrite of Queensland’s property laws
Queensland’s property laws will be replaced with new, modernised legislation, which will include establishing mandatory disclosure rules to make it easier for home buyers. The Property Law Bill, which passed Parliament on 25 October 2023, was informed by the 232 recommendations made by the Queensland University of Technology’s (QUT’s) Commercial and Property Law Research Centre following its in-depth review of the state’s property laws from 2013-18 (25 October 2023). Read more here.
New NBN regulation will promote competition and long-term interests of Australians
The ACCC has accepted NBN Co’s latest proposed variation to its Special Access Undertaking (SAU), which includes measures designed to protect consumers from sharp price rises, reduce barriers to entry for new retailers and create incentives to fix systemic issues that drive poor NBN consumer experience. The SAU sets the rules for how broadband providers will access the NBN over the coming decades and will apply until 2040 (17 October 2023). Read more here.
First female chief justice Susan Kiefel retires after 'masterfully' presiding over High Court for six years
Australia's first female High Court chief justice, Susan Kiefel, has bid goodbye to the court, where she has worked for the past 16 years. She was bid farewell on 16 October 2023. Read more here.
Historic hate crime and serious vilification laws passed in Queensland
The public display, distribution or publication of prohibited hate symbols will become a criminal offence in Queensland, significantly strengthening the state’s response to hate crimes. The historic laws passed in Parliament on 12 October 2023 will protect Queenslanders from the distress associated with the display of symbols that are representative of an ideology of extreme prejudice against a particular religious, ethnic, gender, or other relevant group (12 October 2023). Read more here.
Independent review of the National Cooperative Scheme on Unexplained Wealth
Mr Andrew Cappie-Wood AO has been appointed to independently review the National Cooperative Scheme on Unexplained Wealth (the National Scheme). The National Scheme allows participating jurisdictions to access information-gathering provisions under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 and improves information sharing between the Commonwealth, states and territories in relation to unexplained wealth proceedings and organised crime investigations (12 October 2023). Read more here.
Justices of the Peace Branch Strategic Plan 2022-2026
On 9 October 2023, the Justice of the Peace Branch released its 2022-2026 Strategic Plan. The strategic direction of the Justices of the Peace Branch is underpinned by the Department of Justice and Attorney General Strategic Plan 2022-26 and the Justice Services Divisional Plan 2022-26. Read more here.
CPI rose 1.2 per cent in the September 2023 quarter
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose 1.2 per cent in the September 2023 quarter and 5.4 per cent annually, according to the latest data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS). Michelle Marquardt, ABS head of prices statistics, said “CPI rose 1.2 per cent in the September quarter, higher than the 0.8 per cent rise in the June 2023 quarter. The rise this quarter however continued to be lower than those seen throughout 2022”. Read more here.
Census snapshot shows changes in agricultural workforce
Australia’s agricultural workforce is steadily growing and changing, with more women and young people joining the sector. The ABARES Insights Snapshot of Australia’s agricultural workforce shows the changing state of the agricultural workforce based on data from the 2021 Census of Population and Housing. Read more here.
ACCC Childcare inquiry 2023
On 1 October 2023, the ACCC released its second interim report for the inquiry into childcare services. This second interim report makes draft findings and recommendations regarding the costs of providing childcare services, the nature of competition in childcare markets, the profitability and viability of the sector, and the effectiveness of Australia’s existing price regulation mechanisms in aiding affordability of childcare. Read more here.
Appointment of additional Members to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal
The Australian Government has appointed 54 additional members to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) through a transparent and merit-based selection process, conducted in accordance with the AAT appointment guidelines. These appointments follow the 39 appointments announced on 15 September 2023. Read more here.
Magistrates Courts Practice Direction No. 4 of 2023
This Practice Direction applies to a defendant charged with a prescribed sexual offence under section 7 of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 1978 (the Act), whether the defendant was charged before or after the commencement date of 3 October 2023 (s.17 of the Act). The purpose of this Practice Direction is to facilitate procedural consistency in the determination of Applications for Non-Publication Orders. Read more here.
QCAT Practice Direction No. 3 of 2023
The QCAT registry located on Level 11, 259 Queen Street, Brisbane will close on Friday, 22 December 2023 at 4.30pm and re-open on Tuesday, 2 January 2024 at 8.30am. Read more here.
Alpine Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2023] QSC 233
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – ERROR OF LAW – where the applicant is the registered owner of land that is subject to a Vegetation Protection Order made by the respondent – where the applicant claims that the respondent’s decision to approve the Vegetation Protection Order was an improper exercise of power conferred on the respondent by a local law.
Hanna v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2023] FCA 1255
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – appeal from second level decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT2) – where the AAT2 made findings in relation to the applicant’s liability for overpayment of an age pension and the applicable pension rate – where the appeal does not disclose any question of law – whether the AAT2 had jurisdiction – appeal dismissed.
Icon Energy Limited v Chief Executive, Department of Resources [2023] QSC 227
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – ERROR OF LAW – where a delegate of the respondent refused to accept an application by the applicant to renew its authority to prospect pursuant to the provisions of the Petroleum and Gas (Production and Safety) Act 2004 (Qld) – where the applicant contends that the respondent’s delegate made errors of law in assessing and refusing the renewal application – whether the respondent’s decision to reject the applicant’s renewal application should be set aside.
Infrabuild NSW Pty Ltd v Anti-Dumping Review Panel [2023] FCA 1229
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – application for review of a decision of the Anti-Dumping Review Panel affirming a decision of the Anti-Dumping Commissioner to terminate an investigation into alleged dumping – whether decision of the Anti-Dumping Review Panel involved an improper exercise of power – whether there was a breach of the rules of natural justice in connection with the decision of the Anti-Dumping Review Panel – whether the Anti-Dumping Review Panel erred in law.
Vanderstock v Victoria [2023] HCA 30
Constitutional law (Cth) – duties of excise – exclusive power of Commonwealth Parliament – Scope and operation of s 90 of Constitution – where s 7(1) of Zero and Low Emission Vehicle Distance-based Charge Act 2021 (Vic) ("ZLEV Charge Act") purported to oblige registered operator of zero or low emissions vehicle ("ZLEV") to pay charge for use of ZLEV on "specified roads" ("ZLEV charge") – where "specified roads" defined to include all roads in Victoria and elsewhere in Australia over which public has right of way.
Bills
Bills Introduced – Government
Appropriation Bill (No. 2) 2023
Criminal Law (Coercive Control and Affirmative Consent) and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2023
Housing Availability and Affordability (Planning and Other Legislation Amendment) Bill 2023
Information Privacy and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2023
Public Records Bill 2023
Transport and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2023
Victims of Crime Assistance and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2023
Bills Introduced – Private Member
Crime and Corruption Amendment Bill 2023
Education (General Provisions) (Helping Families with School Costs) Amendment Bill 2023
Bills passed without amendment
Gas Supply and Other Legislation (Hydrogen Industry Development) Amendment Bill 2023
Bills amended during passage
Criminal Code (Serious Vilification and Hate Crimes) and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2023
Bills failed
Liquid Fuel Supply (Minimum Biobased Petrol Content) Amendment Bill 2022
Acts assented to
Criminal Code (Serious Vilification and Hate Crimes) and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2023 No. 26 – Assent 19 October 2023
Gas Supply and Other Legislation (Hydrogen Industry Development) Amendment Act 2023 No. 25 – Assent 19 October 2023
Proclamations commencing Acts made
Proclamation – Police Powers and Responsibilities and Other Legislation Amendment Act (No. 1) 2023 (commencing remaining provisions)
Proclamation No. 1 – Environmental Protection and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2023 (commencing certain provisions)
Proclamation No. 1 – Nature Conservation and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2022 (commencing certain provisions)
Subordinate legislation notified
Education Legislation (Fees) Amendment Regulation 2023
Proclamation – Police Powers and Responsibilities and Other Legislation Amendment Act (No. 1) 2023 (commencing remaining provisions)
Liquor (Mornington) Amendment Regulation 2023
Proclamation No. 1 – Environmental Protection and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2023 (commencing certain provisions)
Wet Tropics (Consequential Amendments) Amendment Management Plan 2023
Proclamation No. 1 – Nature Conservation and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2022 (commencing certain provisions)
Casino Control and Other Legislation Amendment (Postponement) Regulation 2023
Industrial Relations and Other Legislation Amendment (Postponement) Regulation 2023
Health Legislation Amendment Regulation (No. 2) 2023
Health Practitioner Regulation National Law and Other Legislation Amendment (Postponement) Regulation 2023
Nature Conservation (Protected Areas Management) (Apiary Areas) Amendment Regulation 2023
Nature Conservation and Other Legislation (K’gari) Amendment Regulation 2023
Petroleum and Gas (Safety) (Fee Unit Conversion) Amendment Regulation 2023
Subordinate legislation tabled
Building (Queensland Development Code) Amendment Regulation 2023
Criminal Practice Amendment Rule (No. 2) 2023
Economic Development and Other Legislation Amendment Regulation 2023
Education Legislation (Fees) Amendment Regulation 2023
Liquor (Mornington) Amendment Regulation 2023
Local Government (Gold Coast City Council – Suspension of Councillor) Amendment Regulation 2023
Mutual Recognition (Queensland) (Tasmanian Container Deposit Scheme) Amendment Regulation 2023
Proclamation No. 1 – Environmental Protection and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2023 (commencing certain
provisions)
Proclamation – Police Powers and Responsibilities and Other Legislation Amendment Act (No. 1) 2023 (commencing remaining provisions)
Trans-Tasman Mutual Recognition (Queensland) (NT and Tasmanian Container Deposit Schemes) Notice 2023
Wet Tropics (Consequential Amendments) Amendment Management Plan 2023
Proclamation No. 1 – Nature Conservation and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2022 (commencing certain provisions)
Disclaimer
The information in this bulletin is of a general nature and is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavour to provide accurate and timely information, we do not guarantee that the information in this bulletin is accurate at the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future.
Published by:
